Past Perfect vs Past Perfect Continuous
Both tenses talk about actions that happened before another point in the past, but they have different focuses and uses.
Past Perfect
had + past participle
Focuses on completion of an action before another past action.
Past Perfect Continuous
had been + verb-ing
Focuses on the duration or ongoing nature of an action before another past action.
Aspect | Past Perfect | Past Perfect Continuous |
---|---|---|
Focus | Completion of action | Duration of action |
Structure | had + past participle | had been + verb-ing |
Emphasis | Result or accomplishment | Process or continuous activity |
Time Reference | Often with definite time | Often with period of time |
Example | I had finished my homework. | I had been doing my homework. |
Past Perfect
-
When I arrived at the party, my friends had already left.
(The action of leaving was complete)
-
She had visited Paris three times before moving there.
(Emphasizes completed visits)
-
The train had departed by the time we reached the station.
(Completed action before another past event)
Past Perfect Continuous
-
When I arrived at the party, they had been dancing for hours.
(Emphasizes duration of dancing)
-
She had been studying French before moving to Paris.
(Ongoing action over time)
-
My legs ached because I had been running all morning.
(Continuous action with a result)
How the choice of tense changes meaning:
When I saw Sarah, she had painted five pictures.
(Emphasizes the completed result – five finished paintings)
When I saw Sarah, she had been painting all day.
(Emphasizes the ongoing activity throughout the day)
They had lived in Spain for ten years before they moved to Italy.
(Emphasizes the completed period – a finished chapter)
They had been living in Spain for ten years before they moved to Italy.
(Emphasizes the experience of living there over time)
State Verbs
Some verbs typically aren’t used in continuous forms because they describe states rather than actions:
Correct: I had known him for years before we worked together.
Not typical: I had been knowing him for years.
Non-Action vs. Action Meanings
Some verbs change meaning when used in continuous forms:
I had thought he was right. (believed)
I had been thinking about the problem. (actively considering)
Choose the correct form:
- When the police arrived, the thief ________ (had escaped / had been escaping).
- John was tired because he ________ (had worked / had been working) all day.
- By the time I finished school, I ________ (had learned / had been learning) three languages.
- The roads were wet because it ________ (had rained / had been raining).
- She told me she ________ (had written / had been writing) five novels before her first publication.
Hover below for answers!
Create your own sentences:
Write one sentence using Past Perfect and one using Past Perfect Continuous about: